Head-to-head comparison
Fillbook vs Edgewonk
Both are journals for active traders, but they differ in pricing model and focus: Edgewonk is one annual plan built around psychology and discipline tooling, while Fillbook is built around futures and prop-firm account rules, with monthly pricing and a free tier.
Feature and pricing comparison
| Fillbook | Edgewonk | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Free / $14.99/mo / $24.99/mo | Single package: $197 per 12 months, not a monthly subscription |
| Free trial / free tier | Yes14-day no-card trial, then Core or Elite. | No |
| Futures support | YesContract-level P&L using real tick and point values | YesMarkets support for "every market: forex, stocks, futures, crypto, options, indices, commodities"; contract-level detail not independently verified |
| Prop-firm functionality | YesTrailing/static drawdown, daily loss, consistency, breach alerts | Not found in current marketing |
| Automated broker/platform sync | YesTradovate, NinjaTrader; others via CSV | Yes200+ brokers claimed, automated import |
| R-multiple | Yes | Not independently verified |
| Expectancy | Yes | Not independently verified |
| Profit factor | Yes | Not independently verified |
| Drawdown tracking | Yes | Not independently verified |
| Behavioral analytics | YesRevenge trading, overtrading, time-of-day decay | YesDedicated psychology tracking and journaling |
| AI features | YesChat assistant answers questions against your own trade history | Yes"Automated Edge Finder" pattern scanning |
| Trade replay | YesChart view with your planned stop overlaid | Not found in current marketing |
| Backtesting | YesManual what-if trade builder, plus a Preview automated mode against your own uploaded historical data | Not found in current marketing |
| Mobile app | YesInstallable PWA, not a native app store app | Not found in current marketing |
Edgewonk's pricing and features checked directly against Edgewonk's own site on 2026-10-20. Rows marked "Not independently verified" could not be confirmed either way and are not presented as "No."
Which is better for a futures trader?
Edgewonk lists futures among its markets and shows Tradovate, NinjaTrader and other futures platforms among its supported brokers; contract-level detail wasn't independently verified. Fillbook calculates P&L per contract using each instrument's actual tick and point value.
Which is better for a prop-firm trader?
Edgewonk's plan lists unlimited prop-firm accounts and drawdown analytics, but live prop-firm rule tracking wasn't found in its marketing. Fillbook tracks trailing and static drawdown, daily-loss and consistency against your account's specific rules, with breach alerts on Core.
Which provides stronger behavioral analysis?
Edgewonk is the stronger of the two on journaling-style psychology tooling: mistake tracking, checklists, session report cards, a Tiltmeter and a weekly Edge Finder scan. Fillbook runs rule-based detection for revenge trading, overtrading and time-of-day decay directly from trade history.
Which costs less?
Edgewonk: one plan at $197 billed every 12 months, 14-day money-back guarantee, no free trial (checked 2026-10-20). Fillbook: 14-day free trial, no card required, then a permanent Free plan for one account, or $14.99/mo or $24.99/mo.
See if Fillbook fits how you actually trade
Try Fillbook free for 14 days, no card required, then keep Free or upgrade from $14.99/mo.
Start free trial →Frequently asked questions
It depends how long you stay and what you need. Edgewonk bills $197 once per 12 months; Fillbook bills monthly ($14.99/mo Core, $24.99/mo Elite) and has a permanent Free plan for one account.
Edgewonk advertises automated imports and says over 200 brokers are supported; its page doesn't describe the mechanism, so whether a given platform syncs live or by file wasn't verified. Fillbook auto-syncs NinjaTrader and Tradovate (Core and up) and imports CSVs from most other platforms.
For tracking prop-firm rules such as drawdown limits, daily loss and consistency, Fillbook documents that tracking and Edgewonk's marketing doesn't. For psychology journaling, Edgewonk is the more extensive of the two.
Looking for a switching guide instead? See Edgewonk Alternative.Trading Journal That Shows Why You Win or Lose — Fillbook · Futures Trading Journal: Auto-Sync & Real Tick P&L — Fillbook · Trading Performance Analytics — Fillbook · Pricing · Best Trading Journal (2026): A Verified Comparison — Fillbook
Names, logos and trademarks of brokers, trading platforms, prop firms and other companies mentioned on this page belong to their respective owners and are used only to identify them. Fillbook is independent of them and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any of them, except for the referral relationships disclosed on the Recommended page. Firm rules and fees shown are summaries for reference; always verify them with the firm.