Trading journal comparison
Best Trading Journal: A Verified Comparison
Last reviewed: 2026-08-27 — pricing and features re-checked directly against each product's own site
Searching "best trading journal" mostly surfaces roundup articles that don't disclose a methodology, and some that rank their own product first. This page does neither — every claim below is checked against the product's own pricing or marketing page, and every category winner is tied to a specific, checkable fact, not a house opinion.
Methodology
Each product was evaluated only on functionality stated on its own current pricing or marketing pages, checked directly (not inferred, not copied from a third-party review). Where a feature could not be confirmed either way, it's marked "Not independently verified" rather than counted as absent — a silent pricing page is not proof a feature doesn't exist.
Category picks below require the winning product to have a specific, verifiable edge over the others — not a general impression. Where the evidence doesn't clearly favor one product, no winner is declared for that category. Fillbook is evaluated by the same rules as every competitor here, using what's actually shipped in the product (see lib/calc.ts, lib/behavioral.ts, lib/contracts.ts if you want to check the underlying code yourself).
Quick comparison
| Fillbook | TradeZella | TradesViz | TraderSync | Tradervue | Stonk Journal | Edgewonk | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Free/$14.99/$24.99/mo | $35/$59/$99/mo | Free/$19.99/$29.99/mo | $14.97/$22.47/$31.98/mo | $29.95/$49.95/mo | Free/$10/mo | $197/16mo |
| Free | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | Yes | No |
| Futures support | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Prop-firm functionality | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not found in current marketing | Not found in current marketing | Yes | Not found in current marketing |
| Automated broker/platform sync | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
| Behavioral analytics | Yes | Yes | Not independently verified | Not independently verified | Not found in current marketing | Not independently verified | Yes |
| AI features | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not found in current marketing | Yes | Yes |
Full row-by-row detail for any one product is available on its dedicated comparison page (linked in each platform's section below). Pricing and features checked 2026-08-27 against each product's own site.
Category picks
Best for futures traders: Fillbook
Fillbook calculates P&L, position sizing, and R-multiple per contract using each instrument's actual tick and point value, and this is included on the free plan. TradeZella has comparably deep verified futures tooling (a dedicated calculator confirming 28+ contracts) but no free tier at all — worth a look if budget isn't the deciding factor.
Best for prop-firm rule depth: TradesViz
TradesViz ships presets for 36+ named prop firms across all four drawdown methodologies — the deepest verified out-of-the-box prop-firm coverage of any product checked here. Fillbook tracks the same underlying rule types (trailing/static drawdown, daily loss, consistency) but as rules you configure per account rather than a firm you pick from a list.
Best free plan: Stonk Journal
Stonk Journal's free plan allows unlimited trades and accounts with core analytics included — more generous than Fillbook's free plan (50 trades, one account) or any other free tier checked here. The trade-off: no automated broker sync at any price, stated as "on the roadmap."
Best for AI-assisted analytics and backtesting depth: TraderSync
TraderSync's verified feature set (checked directly on its pricing page) includes automated backtesting across multiple asset classes and trade/market replay with tick precision scaling by tier, alongside its "Cypher" AI assistant — the broadest verified combination of AI, replay, and backtesting depth checked here.
Best for behavioral pattern detection: Fillbook
Fillbook runs rule-based detection for revenge trading, overtrading, time-of-day performance decay, and tilt cascades directly from logged trade history — a specifically named, code-verifiable feature. Edgewonk also markets dedicated psychology tracking and journaling, though the underlying detection mechanism wasn't independently verified.
Every platform, individually
Fillbook
Free plan includes futures support, R-multiple, expectancy, profit factor, and prop-firm drawdown/daily-loss/consistency tracking with breach alerts — features several competitors gate behind a paid tier or don't offer at all. Pro is $14.99/mo, Elite is $24.99/mo.
Not the right fit if you specifically need tick-by-tick trade replay with drawing tools, fully automated backtesting against historical market data, or a native (not installable-web-app) mobile app — TradeZella, TraderSync, and TradesViz each go deeper in one of those areas respectively.
TradeZella
$35–$99/mo, no free tier. Deepest verified paid futures tooling and real-time prop-firm monitoring across 15+ named firms, plus AI-driven trade-leak detection and tick-by-tick replay with drawing tools from the Pro tier up.
Full Fillbook vs. TradeZella comparison →TradesViz
Free (stocks only) to $29.99/mo. The most prop-firm presets of any product here (36+ firms), but futures support requires the $19.99/mo Pro tier — the free plan won't work for a futures trader.
Full Fillbook vs. TradesViz comparison →TraderSync
No free tier, 7-day trial, then $14.97–$31.98/mo (promotional pricing). Confirmed futures support on every tier, automated backtesting, and tiered-precision trade/market replay — no prop-firm features found on its pricing or marketing pages.
Full Fillbook vs. TraderSync comparison →Tradervue
$29.95–$49.95/mo, no confirmed free tier. Broad claimed broker-sync coverage (80+ integrations) and a detailed exit-performance analysis feature — no AI, backtesting, replay, or prop-firm features found in current marketing.
Full Fillbook vs. Tradervue comparison →Stonk Journal
Free (unlimited trades/accounts) or $10/mo Pro. The most generous free tier checked here, with real prop-firm-relevant account separation and compliance scoring — but broker auto-sync is stated as not yet available at any price.
Full Fillbook vs. Stonk Journal comparison →Edgewonk
A single $197-for-16-months package rather than a monthly subscription. Markets dedicated trading psychology tracking and "every market" support, but no prop-firm features, backtesting, replay, or native mobile app were found in current marketing.
How to actually choose
If futures or prop-firm accounts are central to how you trade, start with whichever of Fillbook or TradesViz matches your budget and whether you want firm-specific presets or configurable rules. If deep backtesting and trade replay matter more than prop-firm rules, TraderSync is worth evaluating. If you want to try something with zero cost and no trade limit, Stonk Journal's free plan is the most generous here — just confirm you're comfortable with manual/CSV import rather than live broker sync.
See where Fillbook fits for you
Free plan covers 50 trades on one account with manual entry and CSV import, R-multiple tracking included — no card required.
Start free →Frequently asked questions
No. Fillbook doesn't have affiliate relationships with the products compared here, and this page doesn't declare Fillbook the winner of every category — see the category picks above, several of which go to other products based on verified functionality.
Pricing and features are checked directly against each product's own site; the review date at the top of this page reflects the last verification pass. Competitor products change pricing and features on their own schedule, so treat the linked dates as "accurate as of" rather than permanent.
"Best overall" depends on which features matter most to a given trader, and a single ranking would flatten real trade-offs (price vs. depth, futures vs. stocks focus, configurable rules vs. named-firm presets) that different traders should weigh differently. The category picks are deliberately narrow and evidence-based instead.
It means the feature wasn't confirmed one way or the other from the product's own current pricing or marketing pages — not that the feature is absent. A product's pricing page not mentioning a feature isn't proof it doesn't exist somewhere in the product.
Trading Journal — Fillbook · Trading Journal Software That Shows You What to Fix — Fillbook · Futures Trading Journal — Fillbook · Trading Performance Analytics — Fillbook